
Chasing Skinny: What Is the Pursuit of the Perfect Body Costing Us?
Prefer audio only? Listen here!
If you’ve ever searched for how to stop obsessing over weight, you already know how it goes: the number on the scale shifts and so does your mood, or a transformation photo turns up with your morning coffee and the strong, energetic week you were having suddenly feels like it didn’t count. In this episode, Coach Karen opens with a question many women are carrying: when did getting healthy turn into getting smaller?
Coach Karen shares the story behind her own answer, starting with a figure skating coach who told a room of young athletes they were all fat when she was 13 or 14 and already 5'7". She talks about how that message followed her into 90s fitness culture, and what she sees now in her coaching practice when women arrive worn out from years of dieting and starting over. From there, she gets practical about what to pay attention to besides the scale, and she is clear that wanting to change your body is allowed.
Here's what's covered:
Karen’s experience as a national-level figure skater and the change room moment that taught her to make herself smaller
How 90s fitness culture sold the idea that more exercise and stricter eating were always the answer, and why that voice can still show up when you miss a workout
Why social media comparison can change how you feel about your body without anything about your body changing
The expectations placed on women in midlife, and how they shape body image as we age
The everyday questions Karen asks clients before she looks at a number, from how they’re sleeping to how they feel after a workout
Why tracking progress should include more than a photo or a number on the scale
What a weight target can be carrying emotionally, and why “why that number?” deserves a conversation
How to keep working toward a goal while noticing what is improving, like getting stronger or moving more comfortably
Signs your relationship with food or exercise needs more care, like anxiety after an unplanned meal or exercising because you overate
The moving target: what to do when you reach a goal and immediately decide it isn’t enough, and what “enough” could look like
Why persistent exhaustion and digestive symptoms need attention, and why weight isn’t the automatic explanation
Why eating disorders can affect people at any body size, and when to reach out to a qualified professional
Three questions Karen leaves you with, starting with what you want your body to help you do
If you’re a woman in midlife who is tired of diet culture and wants healthy weight loss that doesn’t take over your week, or you’re looking for women’s fitness over 40 that makes room for your actual life, this episode gives you somewhere to start. Karen wants you to be able to go away for a weekend and enjoy the people you love while you work toward your goals.
“A weight target can carry an enormous emotional job” - Coach Karen
If you want support building a plan that fits your body and the season of life you’re in, check out Coach Karen's programs. And if you know a woman who could use this conversation, send her this episode.
Let’s stay connected!
Come find Karen on Instagram
This podcast is brought to you in partnership with Leah Bryant Co.
The unedited transcript for this episode of FIT4HER Unplugged
More about FIT4HER Unplugged
You've spent decades building a life. Your career, family, and health…you've shown up for all of it. And somewhere in your 40s or 50s, you started noticing that what used to work no longer does. Your body feels different. Your energy isn't there. You're not sure who you are outside of the roles you've been playing. And nobody seems to be talking about all of it at once.
Fit4Her is a podcast for women in midlife who are ready to stop waiting to feel like themselves again.
Hosted by Karen Gallagher, Registered Holistic Nutritionist and Strength and Conditioning Coach with 30 years of experience, this show delivers what most health and wellness content never does: honest, whole-life guidance that covers your body, your mindset, your relationships, and your sense of purpose, without the extremes, the all-or-nothing pressure, or the advice that was never built for a woman at this stage of life.
No single corner of midlife gets left out. Fitness, hormones, identity, relationships, career, empty nest, divorce, purpose - it's all here, and it's all connected.
We'll answer questions like:
What should I eat in perimenopause and menopause?
How do I balance my hormones naturally?
How do I get my energy back in midlife?
How do I find my purpose in midlife?
How do I deal with teenagers while going through menopause?
Is it too late to change careers in my 40s or 50s?
How do I rebuild my life after divorce?
How do I stop feeling invisible as I get older?
This show is for women who are done waiting to feel better and ready to actually do something about it.
If that's you, Karen built this show for you.
